No items found.

Walmart Store Closures Study: Nearby Store Sales Fell 20% a Year Later

Article details
Published:
November 15, 2026
Updated:
Read length:
7
 mins

Stores near 39 Walmart locations that closed from 2019 to 2026 saw shopper traffic and sales fall about 20% a year later, three researchers reported in The Conversation on November 10, 2026.

The study looks back at what past Walmart store closures meant for the businesses around them, not at any current closure plan. For owners of retail centers, its core finding is that losing an anchor cost neighbors more shoppers than it handed them in captured sales (The Conversation).

By the Numbers: Walmart Closures and Nearby Store Sales

  • The sample covered 39 Walmart stores that closed across 20 states from 2019 to 2026 (The Conversation).
  • Nearby stores saw traffic and sales drop about 5% in the first month after a closure and about 6% in the second month (The Conversation).
  • The decline reached about 17% by the ninth month and about 20% a year after the closure (The Conversation).
  • Each figure compares nearby stores with similar stores near Walmart locations that stayed open (The Conversation).
  • Stores with a higher share of revenue from online orders saw a smaller drop in sales (The Conversation).

What the Walmart Store Closures Study Found

The authors are marketing professors Vivek Astvansh of Binghamton University, Preetinder Kaur of the University of Guelph and Pushpinder Gill of Toronto Metropolitan University (The Conversation). Their article links to a 2026 working paper titled When the Anchor Closes: Walmart Store Closures and Nearby Retail Activity, which is listed as unpublished (working paper DOI record).

We found no peer reviewed journal version of the paper as of November 15, 2026. The authors disclosed no funding from companies that would benefit from the article (The Conversation).

The researchers matched closure dates with monthly store-level data on shopper traffic and spending. For each closed Walmart, they picked nearby businesses that were not Walmarts. They then compared those stores with businesses near Walmart locations that remained open (The Conversation).

The decline was not a one-time dip. It grew over the year, from roughly 5% in month one to about 20% at month twelve (The Conversation). Fortune republished the article on November 14, 2026, under a Creative Commons license, so it is the same study rather than a second source.

A Note on the 'Roughly a Quarter' Figure

The article's opening says nearby stores saw traffic and sales slump "by roughly a quarter" compared with stores near Walmarts that stayed open (The Conversation). Its detailed results give lower numbers: about 17% at nine months and about 20% at one year.

The article does not explain the difference. A quarter would be about 25%, or 5 percentage points above the one-year figure. This post uses the detailed monthly figures, since they carry specific time frames.

Why Nearby Stores Lost Shoppers Instead of Gaining Them

The authors describe a tug of war between two forces. Competitive relief helps neighbors because a strong rival is gone. Agglomeration loss hurts them because fewer people have a reason to visit the area at all (The Conversation).

An agglomeration effect is the benefit stores get from sitting near other stores that draw shoppers. A trip to Walmart can lead to a stop at a nearby restaurant, pharmacy, salon or service business (The Conversation). When the anchor left, that shared traffic went with it.

Traffic and sales fell together, and that detail matters. If neighbors were only selling less to the same visitors, spending per visit would have dropped. Instead, the authors found that fewer shoppers came at all (The Conversation).

Earlier research found that a Walmart opening causes sales at nearby existing stores to fall (Marketing Science study). The new work, the authors say, is the first to study what happens when a Walmart or other anchor closes (The Conversation).

Which Tenants Held Up Better After an Anchor Store Closing

Not every neighbor was hit equally. Stores that competed more directly with Walmart, such as grocery stores and close substitutes, posted better sales after a closure than stores that did not compete (The Conversation).

Well-known brands held up better than unbranded businesses. Stores surrounded by more outlets of their own brand also fared better (The Conversation). A recognizable name gives shoppers their own reason to visit.

Online reach helped too. Stores that earned a larger share of revenue from online orders saw a smaller sales drop after a Walmart closed (The Conversation). Those businesses depend less on people driving to a cluster of stores.

What the Findings Mean for Retail Landlords and Shopping Center Investors

For investors, the study puts numbers on a risk that is usually discussed in general terms. An anchor's value to a center sits partly outside its own rent and sales. The authors call this an externality, an effect on other parties that market prices do not reflect (The Conversation).

The authors write that commercial property owners should see losing an anchor as more than an empty storefront, because it can reduce demand across the rest of a property (The Conversation). They add that a replacement tenant's ability to generate trips matters, not just how fast the space is filled.

Several common deal terms connect to these findings. A co-tenancy clause lets an in-line tenant pay reduced rent or leave if a named anchor goes dark. Shadow-anchored centers sit next to a big box they do not own, so they carry the traffic risk without control of the anchor box.

The tenant traits the study links to resilience are also visible in a rent roll. Grocery and close competitors, national brands, multi-unit operators and tenants with online sales each showed smaller declines in the data (The Conversation). The study does not measure rents, vacancy or property values, so any effect on those is not addressed.

The findings come as retail space stays tight nationally. Our coverage of Colliers' third quarter 2026 retail vacancy report and the Hines retail real estate outlook for 2026 tracks that backdrop. Our post on Children's Place closing sales across its fleet covers a different kind of store closure.

Morabito Investment Group Analysis: Most of the Loss Came Later

About 75% of the first-year decline arrived after the first month, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of the figures in The Conversation. We subtracted the first-month drop of about 5% from the one-year drop of about 20%, then divided the 15-point gap by 20.

By the same figures, the drop grew about fourfold over the year. The 11 points added between month two and month nine made up about 55% of the one-year decline (The Conversation). Early leasing or sales data after a closure may therefore understate the full effect.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens to nearby stores when Walmart closes?

In a study of 39 Walmart closures in 20 states from 2019 to 2026, nearby stores saw traffic and sales fall about 20% a year later (The Conversation). The comparison group was similar stores near Walmarts that stayed open. Fewer shoppers visited, rather than shoppers spending less per trip.

What happens when an anchor store closes?

The researchers found that the loss of shared shopper traffic outweighed the gain from losing a competitor (The Conversation). They describe the anchor as both a rival and a traffic generator for nearby businesses. Grocery stores, known brands and stores with online sales held up better.

Is the Walmart closure study peer reviewed?

The article links to a 2026 working paper by Gill, Kaur and Astvansh that is listed as unpublished (working paper DOI record). We did not find a journal version as of November 15, 2026. The authors disclosed no funding from companies that would benefit from the article (The Conversation).

Key Takeaways

  • Stores near 39 closed Walmarts saw traffic and sales fall about 20% a year after closure, versus stores near Walmarts that stayed open.
  • The decline deepened over time, from about 5% in the first month to about 17% by month nine.
  • Grocery stores, known brands, multi-unit operators and stores with online sales held up better than other neighbors.

Bottom Line

The study suggests an anchor closure works more like a slow drain on a shopping area than a gift to its rivals. The detailed figures point to a 20% decline after one year, below the "roughly a quarter" in the article's opening.

For retail landlords and shopping center investors, the research adds data to the question of how much of a center's traffic depends on one tenant.

Image credit: Photo by KDavid Montero on Unsplash.

Sources

Disclaimer: This article is for general information and education only. It is not investment, financial, legal, tax or accounting advice, and it is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or property. Morabito Investment Group does not guarantee that the information is complete, accurate or current. Figures, forecasts and opinions from third parties belong to their sources. All investments carry risk, including loss of principal, and past results do not guarantee future results. Do your own research and consult a licensed professional before making any investment, financing or other decision. You use this information at your own risk.

Read more articles