Self Storage Market Report 2026: Suburbs Get 59% of New Supply as Rents Fall 1.8%
Suburbs took 59% of the self storage built in the 100 largest U.S. metros from 2016 to 2025, StorageCafe reported on October 21, 2026. Urban cores took the other 41%, a split that roughly matches the existing stock, according to StorageCafe.
The development story is only half of this self storage market report 2026 picture. Yardi Matrix said national advertised rents fell 1.8% from a year earlier in September 2026, according to Yardi Matrix. Fewer projects are underway, yet rents have not recovered.
By the Numbers: Self Storage Market Report 2026
- 59% suburban, 41% urban: the split of new self storage space built in the 100 largest metros from 2016 to 2025 (StorageCafe).
- 41 to 42 metros: the number that built at least half of their new supply inside principal cities (StorageCafe; Connect CRE).
- Down 1.8%: national advertised street rates in September 2026, year over year (Yardi Matrix).
- 3.3% vs. 1.0%: the annual rate drop at self storage REITs compared with non-REIT operators (Modern Storage Media).
- 43.8 million square feet: net rentable space under construction at the end of September, or 2.1% of existing stock, down 40 basis points from a year earlier (Modern Storage Media).
What the StorageCafe Study Found
StorageCafe, a Yardi Systems site, counted census tracts inside each metro's principal cities as urban and the rest of the metro as suburban. It used Yardi Matrix construction data and Census Bureau population figures, according to StorageCafe. Senior editor Maria Gatea wrote the study, with data analysis by Victor Maghear.
The report gives two counts for urban-led metros. Its key takeaways say 41 metros built most of their new supply in urban areas, while the body says 42 built half or more there, according to StorageCafe. Connect CRE used the figure of 42.
Paul Bubny of Connect CRE framed the trend as a shift toward urban sites in mid-sized metros. He noted that fast in-migration to Sun Belt cities has created renter-heavy, apartment-dense urban populations.
The Largest Suburban Builders: New York, Atlanta and Dallas
New York-Newark-Jersey City delivered about 25 million square feet over the decade, the most of any metro, and 69% of it was suburban, according to StorageCafe. New York City has restricted self storage in some industrial business zones since 2017. That pushed projects toward New Jersey and the suburban ring.
Atlanta added close to 15 million square feet in its suburbs, from Cherokee County to Henry County. Dallas-Fort Worth added about 14.5 million suburban square feet, and 75% of its 2.9 million square foot pipeline is suburban, according to StorageCafe.
Chicago built about 10 million square feet in its suburbs and 3.2 million in the city. In May 2025, Chicago banned self storage in most business, commercial and downtown districts, according to StorageCafe. Phoenix added about 15 million square feet, mostly in places such as Gilbert, Chandler and Surprise.
Some metros barely built in their cores at all. Boston put 99% of about 8 million square feet in its suburbs, and Detroit put 95% of about 6.5 million there, according to StorageCafe. Riverside-San Bernardino was 89% suburban.
Where Urban Self Storage Is Growing
Las Vegas led the urban side, with 96% of about 6.4 million square feet inside city limits, according to StorageCafe. Its entire pipeline is urban. The study points to underused commercial parcels, small lots and apartment living without basements.
Other urban leaders include Colorado Springs at 89%, Wichita at 86% and El Paso at 85%, according to StorageCafe. Cape Coral-Fort Myers built 83% of its new supply in urban areas, more than 3 million square feet. San Antonio was 82% urban out of about 6.4 million square feet, and Tucson was 80%.
Local codes help explain the pattern. El Paso allows self storage by right in all commercial, industrial and apartment districts, according to StorageCafe. Cape Coral changed its code in 2024 to steer new facilities toward urban and mixed-use sites.
A Morabito Investment Group analysis of the StorageCafe figures finds that Las Vegas and San Antonio together added about 12.8 million square feet. Applying each metro's urban share gives about 11.4 million square feet inside city limits, or 89% of the pair's new supply.
Self Storage Market Data: Rents and the Construction Pipeline
The Yardi Matrix national report for October 2026, published October 19, covers 228 markets. Advertised rates fell 1.8% year over year in September, and all of the top 30 metros posted declines from August, according to Yardi Matrix.
REITs cut harder than private operators. Self storage REITs posted a 3.3% annual drop in advertised rates, compared with 1.0% for non-REIT operators, according to Modern Storage Media. That is a gap of 2.3 percentage points.
About 43.8 million net rentable square feet were under construction at the end of September. That equals 2.1% of existing inventory, down from about 2.5% a year earlier, according to Modern Storage Media. The outlet said longer lease-ups and softer demand have kept the slowdown from lifting rates.
Why It Matters for Investors
Self storage is a proximity business, as Maghear put it, according to Connect CRE. Customers want a facility close to home, so urban sites can work even when they cost more to build. He added that some markets are still expanding outward while others are moving the next projects inside city limits.
Developers quoted by StorageCafe describe the tradeoff. Tom de Jong of Colliers said getting project approvals is one of the biggest hurdles in many urban areas, according to StorageCafe. He also said multi-story construction costs have risen sharply.
Marc Goodin, CEO of Storage Authority Franchising, said urban sites have more renters in a given radius but face more competition and higher costs, according to StorageCafe. Many developers now choose suburban land for that reason.
Demand links storage to housing. Renter density matters, which is why trends such as the national multifamily vacancy rate in the third quarter of 2026 are worth tracking next to storage data. Investors comparing niche property types may also look at manufactured housing community rent growth in 2026.
Implications for Owners and Developers
- Falling street rates alongside a shrinking pipeline suggest the reset is about supply still leasing up, not only weak demand.
- The 2.3 point gap between REIT and private operator rate cuts shows that pricing strategy differs by owner type. Sales comps and rent assumptions may need to reflect who owns nearby facilities.
- Zoning matters as much as demand. Bans or limits in New York City and Chicago push supply outward, while codes in El Paso and Cape Coral pull it inward.
- Urban projects face higher land and building costs but, in some metros, less nearby competition. Underwriting has to weigh both.
New storage supply is also slowing alongside other retail-adjacent building. MIG covered how retail construction starts fell to their lowest level since 2016 in the third quarter of 2026. For more on property types MIG follows, see its commercial real estate sector page.
What to Watch
Watch whether the 30 largest metros keep posting monthly rent declines into the fourth quarter. Watch the pipeline share, which stood at 2.1% of stock in September, according to Modern Storage Media.
Also watch local zoning. Chicago's 2025 rules and New York City's 2017 limits show how quickly city policy can move where storage gets built.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does the self storage market report show for 2026?
Yardi Matrix said national advertised rates fell 1.8% year over year in September 2026, and all top 30 metros fell from August, according to Yardi Matrix. About 43.8 million square feet was under construction, or 2.1% of stock, according to Modern Storage Media.
What is the self storage market outlook?
Construction is slowing, with the pipeline down 40 basis points as a share of stock from a year earlier, according to Modern Storage Media. The same report said longer lease-ups and weaker demand have so far kept that slowdown from producing rate gains.
Is new self storage being built in cities or suburbs?
Mostly suburbs. StorageCafe found 59% of new space in the 100 largest metros from 2016 to 2025 was suburban, but 41 to 42 metros built at least half of it in urban areas, according to StorageCafe.
Key Takeaways
- Suburbs took 59% of the self storage built in the 100 largest U.S. metros from 2016 to 2025, StorageCafe found.
- National advertised self storage rates fell 1.8% year over year in September 2026, with REITs down 3.3% and private operators down 1.0%, per Yardi Matrix data.
- Las Vegas and San Antonio together added about 12.8 million square feet, roughly 89% of it inside city limits, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of StorageCafe data.
Bottom Line
Self storage development has spread into city cores in mid-sized Sun Belt and Mountain West metros, while large coastal and Midwest metros still build mostly in suburbs. Rents are falling even as the pipeline shrinks. For investors, location, zoning and nearby supply remain the key variables to study.
Image credit: Photo by Adam Winger on Unsplash.
Sources
- StorageCafe, Suburban Giants and Urban Risers: Where America's 100 Largest Metros Fall on the Self Storage Map, https://www.storagecafe.com/blog/urban-vs-suburban-self-storage-construction/
- Connect CRE, Self-Storage Development Boom Shifts to Mid-Sized Urban Markets, https://www.connectcre.com/stories/self-storage-development-boom-shifts-to-mid-sized-urban-markets/
- Yardi Matrix, Matrix Self Storage National Report, October 2026, https://www.yardimatrix.com/self-storage-national/matrix-self-storage-national-report-october-2026/
- Modern Storage Media, Yardi Matrix Releases October 2026 Self-Storage National Report, https://www.modernstoragemedia.com/news/yardi-matrix-releases-october-2026-self-storage-national-report
Disclaimer: This article is for general information and education only. It is not investment, financial, legal, tax or accounting advice, and it is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or property. Morabito Investment Group does not guarantee that the information is complete, accurate or current. Figures, forecasts and opinions from third parties belong to their sources. All investments carry risk, including loss of principal, and past results do not guarantee future results. Do your own research and consult a licensed professional before making any investment, financing or other decision. You use this information at your own risk.
This article is for general information only. It is not legal, tax, financial, or investment advice, and it is not an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security. Talk to your own advisors before acting on anything in it. Views are current as of the publish date and may change without notice.








