No items found.

Replacement Cost Commercial Real Estate: Buildings Trade at 44% to 87% of Cost

Article details
Published:
October 24, 2026
Updated:
Read length:
7
 mins

Existing commercial buildings trade at about 44% to 87% of published construction costs, depending on property type, Colliers said in an October 22, 2026 report on replacement cost commercial real estate.

Put another way, values sit 13% to 56% below what it would cost to build the same space today, as CRE Daily summarized the finding on October 23. Colliers says high building and financing costs are holding back new projects. That limits future supply and helps the income outlook for owners of existing buildings.

By the Numbers

  • Existing assets trade at roughly 44% to 87% of published construction costs, by property type, per Colliers.
  • Contractor bid prices rose 5.3% in the year through August 2026, per Colliers.
  • CoStar expects multifamily completions to fall 23% in 2026 and 19% in 2027, as cited by Colliers.
  • The all-property cap rate for REIT-quality assets was 6.1% at the end of the third quarter of 2026, per Green Street data in a Colliers snapshot reported by CRE Daily on Yahoo Finance.
  • Office cap rates sat at 7.4% and industrial at 5.1%, a 230 basis point gap, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of the same Green Street figures.

What Is Replacement Cost in Real Estate?

Replacement cost is what it would take to build a similar property from scratch today. It covers land, materials, labor, fees and financing during construction. When a building sells for less than that figure, a buyer gets the space for less than a developer would spend to create it.

That gap matters because it shapes new supply. Developers usually build only when a finished project will be worth more than its total development cost. When values fall below cost, fewer projects start, and existing owners face less new competition from modern buildings.

The report was written by Rachael Rothman, who leads national capital markets research at Colliers. Her summary line was direct: "With few new projects starting, owners of existing buildings face less new competition over the next two years."

Replacement Cost Commercial Real Estate by Property Type

The discount to replacement cost varies widely across sectors, Colliers found. Here is how each major property type compares.

  • Downtown office: Trades at less than half of construction cost. Colliers says results still depend on building quality, leasing and local demand.
  • Open-air retail: Values are about 70% of construction costs. High building and financing costs limit speculative projects, so new competition is scarce.
  • Hotels: CoStar expects supply to grow only about 0.5% a year through 2027, because new hotels face financial hurdles.
  • Warehouses: Values sit closest to replacement cost of any type in the analysis. Colliers calls this the exception to watch.
  • New Sun Belt multifamily: The one case where new buildings are worth more than they cost to build.

For most other property types, Colliers expects low construction starts to keep deliveries light for the next 12 to 24 months.

Why New Apartments Still Are Not Getting Built

Apartments show that a favorable valuation gap is not enough on its own to restart development. In Mid-America Apartment Communities' (MAA) Sun Belt markets, new communities trade at cap rates in the mid-to-upper 4% range, Colliers reported. Older properties trade in the high-5% to low-6% range.

A cap rate, or capitalization rate, is a property's yearly net operating income divided by its price. A lower cap rate means buyers pay more for each dollar of income. At those levels, new apartments are worth more than their construction cost.

Starts have still fallen, because lenders have tightened and loans cost more, Colliers said. CoStar's forecast of 23% fewer completions in 2026 and 19% fewer in 2027 reflects that squeeze. MIG covered recent apartment pricing in our report on apartment cap rates holding at 5.4%.

The Warehouse Exception

Industrial is where the supply shield is thinnest, Colliers said. Industrial construction activity has recovered from its late-2025 low point.

Warehouse development site sales fell to 45 transactions in 2025, down 68% from 2021. But dollar volume of those site sales through the third quarter of 2026 already tops the 2025 total. Colliers says industrial underwriting should assume a shorter period of supply protection.

Investor demand for industrial is also strong. Industrial trading averaged about $34 billion a quarter in the first nine months of 2026, versus an implied 10-year average of about $27 billion, per CRE Daily. The headline deal was Americold's $1.3 billion, nine-property cold storage portfolio.

Commercial Real Estate Cap Rates by Property Type

Colliers paired the cost study with a third-quarter capital markets snapshot. It used Green Street cap rates for REIT-quality assets at quarter end, which Colliers notes are not market-wide averages, per CRE Daily.

  • Hotels: 8.5%
  • Office: 7.4%
  • Malls: 6.6%
  • Strip centers: 6.3%
  • All property: 6.1%
  • Multifamily: 5.4%
  • Industrial: 5.1%

Multifamily and mall prices fell from a year earlier, while every other type in the table rose, the report said. Office trades 230 basis points above industrial, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of the Green Street figures. A basis point is one hundredth of a percentage point.

The 10-year Treasury yield closed at 5.00% on October 23, 2026, per the U.S. Treasury daily par yield curve. That leaves the 6.1% all-property cap rate about 110 basis points above the 10-year, by the same MIG analysis. Multifamily's 5.4% rate is just 40 basis points above it.

MIG covered the recent move in our report on the 10-year yield falling below 5%.

How Capital Is Moving in Each Sector

Colliers says capital is available, but its cost is the main obstacle, per CRE Daily. Banks, insurers, private credit funds and securitized lenders stayed active, and competition among them kept credit spreads attractive.

In apartments, asking rents rose 3.2% from a year earlier on the West Coast, but they fell 0.3% on the East Coast and 1.4% in the Sun Belt. Colliers notes going-in cap rates sit only slightly above borrowing costs, which leaves little positive leverage.

Office CMBS delinquency rose to 12.16% in September, versus 8.02% for all CMBS, per Trepp data in the same report. Notable third-quarter deals included the $435 million sale of One Marina Park Drive in Boston and the $233 million sale of the 542-unit Camden Harbor View in Long Beach, California.

In hospitality, Trinity Investments bought a two-property, 1,594-room Orlando hotel portfolio for $1.3 billion, according to the same Colliers snapshot.

Implications for Investors, Owners and Developers

For owners, a value below replacement cost acts as a brake on new supply. Fewer new buildings can support rents and occupancy for well-located existing assets over time. Colliers ties that outlook to net operating income, the income left after operating costs.

For buyers, the data shows why buying can cost less than building in many sectors today. That does not make every discounted building a sound investment. Colliers stresses that downtown office results still depend on quality, leasing and local demand.

For developers, including commercial, build-to-suit and build-to-rent sponsors, the math is harder. A project needs rents high enough to cover today's construction and loan costs. MIG tracked those cost pressures in JLL's construction cost outlook and in our look at stalled commercial property prices.

What to Watch

  • Warehouse starts and land sales, since rising industrial construction could erode the supply advantage Colliers describes.
  • Apartment lending terms, which will shape whether new Sun Belt projects start despite strong values.
  • Contractor bid prices, after the 5.3% increase in the year through August.
  • The 10-year Treasury yield, which sets the baseline that cap rates are measured against.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is replacement cost in real estate?

Replacement cost is the total cost to build a comparable property today, including land, materials, labor and financing. Colliers found existing commercial buildings trade at about 44% to 87% of published construction costs. That means many buildings sell for less than they would cost to build.

What are current cap rates by property type?

At the end of the third quarter of 2026, Green Street cap rates were 8.5% for hotels, 7.4% for office, 6.6% for malls and 6.3% for strip centers. Multifamily was 5.4%, industrial 5.1% and all property 6.1%, per CRE Daily. These figures reflect REIT-quality assets.

How do you calculate replacement cost for commercial real estate?

Investors add up the cost of land, hard costs such as materials and labor, and soft costs such as design, permits, fees and construction financing. They then compare that total with a building's market value. Colliers used published construction costs for its comparison.

Key Takeaways

  • Existing commercial buildings trade at about 44% to 87% of published construction costs, Colliers said on October 22, 2026.
  • Warehouses trade closest to replacement cost, and new Sun Belt apartments are worth more than they cost to build.
  • Office cap rates are 230 basis points above industrial, and the 6.1% all-property rate is about 110 basis points above the 10-year Treasury close of October 23, 2026, per a Morabito Investment Group analysis.

Bottom Line

Colliers' data shows that in most sectors, buying an existing building costs well less than building a new one. That gap is slowing new supply, which can help existing owners face less competition. Warehouses and new apartments are the main exceptions, and they deserve closer underwriting.

Image credit: Photo by Hardco Group on Unsplash.

Sources

Disclaimer: This article is for general information and education only. It is not investment, financial, legal, tax or accounting advice, and it is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or property. Morabito Investment Group does not guarantee that the information is complete, accurate or current. Figures, forecasts and opinions from third parties belong to their sources. All investments carry risk, including loss of principal, and past results do not guarantee future results. Do your own research and consult a licensed professional before making any investment, financing or other decision. You use this information at your own risk.

Read more articles