Private Real Estate Cap Rates Sit Below the 10-Year Treasury While REITs Price at 5.7%
Third-quarter 2026 private appraisal cap rates averaged 4.4%, versus 5.7% for REITs and 4.8% for the 10-year Treasury, according to Bisnow. Private real estate vs REITs shows a wide valuation gap, and private appraisals sit below the Treasury yield for the first time since at least 2022.
A cap rate is net operating income divided by property value. A lower cap rate means a higher value for the same income. Bisnow reported the data on November 18, 2026, from Nareit's REITworld conference in Atlanta.
By the Numbers
- 4.4%: the NCREIF private appraisal cap rate average in Q3 2026 (Bisnow).
- 5.7%: the Nareit implied cap rate for public REITs in Q3 2026 (Bisnow).
- 85 basis points: the rise in the 10-year Treasury yield during Q3, per CenterSquare.
- 40 basis points: the rise in average REIT cap rates in Q3, implying roughly a 7% value loss (CenterSquare).
- 16.2%: the year-to-date average total return for U.S. equity REITs, the best since 2021 (Bisnow).
What the Private Real Estate vs REITs Gap Means
Public REITs reprice every day. Private funds value assets through periodic appraisals, which lag. When rates rise, REIT prices fall quickly and cap rates move up. Private appraisals often stay put.
The gap in the third quarter was large. REITs priced at 5.7% against 4.4% for private appraisals, a spread of 130 basis points, based on a Morabito Investment Group calculation. Private appraisals also sat 40 basis points below the 4.8% Treasury average.
Edward Pierzak, Nareit's senior vice president of research, said stale valuations impede price discovery, limit transaction liquidity and make it harder for investors to redeem capital. He said history shows such divergences always converge, and that REITs outperform private real estate when they do.
Pierzak said private equity funds may have hoped the market would come to them. The gap began in 2022 when the Federal Reserve started raising rates. With a September hike done and a December hike widely expected, pressure to update appraisals is rising.
How Much Could Private Values Move
Steve Sakwa of Evercore said his firm estimates private-market cap rates sit 25 to 50 basis points above appraised levels, depending on property type. He said there is still a decent disconnect.
If a 4.4% appraisal cap rate moved to 4.65% to 4.90%, with income unchanged, values would fall about 5% to 10%, based on our arithmetic. That is a scenario, not a forecast.
CenterSquare found the REIT repricing was smaller than the rise in Treasury yields. The 40 basis point cap rate increase equals about a 7% value drop. The firm said the sector is under 30% levered, about 90% of its debt is fixed-rate, and the earnings impact is below 1%.
REIT Returns and Investor Flows
U.S. equity REITs returned 16.2% on average year to date, their best result since 2021, according to Bisnow citing a FTSE Nareit report. REITs returned 2.9% in 2025 and 8.7% in 2024, versus 18% and 25% for the S&P 500 in those years.
Jiyang Zhang of Cohen and Steers said valuations are cheap and the bar is low, so more things can go right than wrong in the asset class. Sakwa said money is rotating out of technology into the rest of the market.
Bisnow also reported that REIT stock prices are closer to underlying asset values than in several years, which has put REIT mergers on hold. For earlier coverage, see our report on REITs and interest rates.
Implications for Investors, Owners and Developers
Investors in private funds should ask how often assets are appraised and how appraisals compare with recent sales. Redemption queues can lengthen when valuations lag, as our coverage of BREIT impairments showed.
The 10-year Treasury closed at 5.12% on November 12, 2026, according to Commercial Observer. That is above the 4.8% Q3 average, so the gap may be wider now than in the quarter's data. Read our note on the 10-year Treasury at 5.10% for context.
For owners, the lesson is practical. Public markets signal where private prices may head. Sellers who rely on older appraisals may find buyers using higher cap rates.
What to Watch
Watch the Q4 NCREIF appraisal data for movement toward the Treasury yield. Watch the Fed's December 8 and 9 meeting, since another increase would widen the gap further. Watch whether REITs buy or sell assets to take advantage of private pricing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are REITs better than private real estate?
Neither is always better. Nareit's Pierzak said that when valuation gaps close, REITs have outperformed private real estate, but that is a historical pattern and not a guarantee, per Bisnow.
What is a REIT cap rate?
It is the implied cap rate based on REIT share prices and the income of their properties. Nareit put the Q3 2026 average at 5.7%.
Why do private real estate values lag REITs?
Private values come from periodic appraisals, while REIT shares trade daily. Pierzak said stale valuations limit price discovery and liquidity.
Key Takeaways
- Q3 2026 private appraisal cap rates averaged 4.4%, versus 5.7% for REITs and 4.8% for the 10-year Treasury.
- A 25 to 50 basis point reset in private cap rates would imply roughly 5% to 10% lower values, holding income constant.
- REITs returned 16.2% on average year to date, their best since 2021.
Bottom Line
The gap between public and private pricing is a useful warning sign. It does not tell investors what to do, but it explains why private fund valuations deserve a closer look. This article is informational and is not investment advice.
Image credit: Bisnow, via Private Equity Lags REITs In Getting CRE Portfolios Up To Market Speed.
Sources
- Bisnow, "Private Equity Lags REITs In Getting CRE Portfolios Up To Market Speed," https://www.bisnow.com/news/national/capital-markets/private-equity-lags-reits-in-getting-cre-portfolios-up-to-market-speed
- CenterSquare, "Q3 2026 REIT Cap Rate Perspective," https://www.centersquare.com/insights/q3-2026-reit-cap-rate-perspective-leverage-growth-and-the-rate-story/
- Nareit, "FTSE Nareit U.S. Real Estate Index Returns," https://www.reit.com/sites/default/files/returns/DomesticReturns.pdf
- Commercial Observer, "For Bank Lenders in Commercial Real Estate, Higher-for-Longer Rates Are a Test," https://commercialobserver.com/2026/11/bank-lenders-commercial-real-estate-higher-for-longer-rates-strategies/
Disclaimer: This article is for general information and education only. It is not investment, financial, legal, tax or accounting advice, and it is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or property. Morabito Investment Group does not guarantee that the information is complete, accurate or current. Figures, forecasts and opinions from third parties belong to their sources. All investments carry risk, including loss of principal, and past results do not guarantee future results. Do your own research and consult a licensed professional before making any investment, financing or other decision. You use this information at your own risk.
This article is for general information only. It is not legal, tax, financial, or investment advice, and it is not an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security. Talk to your own advisors before acting on anything in it. Views are current as of the publish date and may change without notice.








