No items found.

Investment Sales NYC: Q3 2026 Volume Falls 25.2% to $6.73B as Deal Count Rises

Article details
Published:
October 26, 2026
Updated:
Read length:
7
 mins

New York City investment sales totaled $6.73 billion across 614 transactions in the third quarter of 2026, down 25.2% from a year earlier, Ariel Property Advisors reported in October 2026. Deal count still rose 0.7%, and year-to-date volume reached $23.69 billion, up 9% from the first three quarters of 2025, according to Ariel Property Advisors.

The investment sales NYC picture for the quarter is divided: more buildings are trading, but fewer of the largest institutional deals are closing. A separate Avison Young report found the same pattern in Manhattan, where volume fell while the yearly deal count kept climbing.

By the Numbers

  • Citywide volume for the first three quarters of 2026 was $23.69 billion across 1,914 transactions and 2,496 properties, per Ariel Property Advisors.
  • Excluding trades of $250 million or more, third-quarter volume rose 4.0% from a year earlier, per Ariel Property Advisors.
  • Multifamily sales in Manhattan, the Bronx, Queens and Brooklyn reached $6.99 billion through three quarters, up 7.9%, per Connect CRE.
  • Brooklyn led multifamily sales in the third quarter with $693.8 million, ahead of Manhattan below 96th Street at $685.2 million, per Commercial Observer.
  • Manhattan investment sales fell 27% to $2.5 billion in the third quarter, Avison Young found, per Commercial Observer.
  • Ariel's average citywide deal size was about $11.0 million in the third quarter of 2026, down from about $14.8 million a year earlier, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of Ariel data.

What Happened to Investment Sales NYC in the Third Quarter

The third quarter was the third straight quarterly decline from a $13.91 billion peak in the fourth quarter of 2025, Ariel Property Advisors said. Earlier in 2026 the trend was considerably stronger, with first-quarter volume up 36% from a year earlier and second-quarter volume up 31%.

Ariel tied most of the third-quarter drop to a few very large trades in 2025. The largest was the $1.08 billion sale of 590 Madison Avenue. In the third quarter of 2025, five trades of $250 million or more totaled $3.08 billion; in 2026, two such trades totaled $568 million, Ariel reported.

Remove those transactions from both periods and comparable volume rose 4.0%. That explains why a 25.2% decline in dollars sat next to a small gain in deal count. The market did not stall; the largest trophy transactions simply did not repeat.

Asset Classes: Multifamily Leads, Special Purpose Surges

Multifamily was the largest asset class through three quarters, at $6.99 billion across 1,044 deals. That equals 29.5% of citywide dollar volume, according to Ariel Property Advisors. Buildings with 10 or more units made up $5.00 billion of that total.

Smaller properties grew fastest. Small multifamily volume rose 19.7% to $1.31 billion, while buildings with 6 to 9 units reached $678.5 million, up 4.3%. The other asset classes moved in different directions:

  • Development sites, including conversions: $5.24 billion, up 9.7%.
  • Office: $5.20 billion across 95 deals, down 2.8%.
  • Retail: $2.27 billion, up 2.5%.
  • Special purpose: $1.93 billion, up 88.4%.
  • Hotel: $1.08 billion, up 18.4%.
  • Industrial, warehouse and storage: $988.3 million, up 3.5%.

All of these figures cover the first three quarters of 2026 and come from Ariel Property Advisors. Development, office and multifamily together account for nearly three of every four dollars traded.

Brooklyn Multifamily Tops Manhattan

Ariel's quarterly multifamily report showed Brooklyn ahead of Manhattan below 96th Street in the third quarter, Commercial Observer reported on October 21, 2026. Brooklyn volume fell 12.8% to $693.8 million, but its deal count rose 12.7% to 178.

Manhattan below 96th Street fell 43.6% to $685.2 million across 58 deals. Across the four boroughs Ariel tracks for multifamily, third-quarter volume fell 23.3% to $1.84 billion. That was the lowest quarterly figure since the first quarter of 2024, per Connect CRE.

Large transactions explain much of the decline. Four multifamily trades of $50 million or more totaled $388.7 million in the third quarter, compared with eight worth $999.2 million a year earlier, per Commercial Observer.

Brooklyn and Manhattan below 96th Street together produced about 75% of the four-borough multifamily total, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of Ariel figures reported by Commercial Observer.

Market-Rate Buildings Draw Most Multifamily Capital

Buildings with at least 75% market-rate units made up 63.1% of third-quarter multifamily dollar volume. Buildings with at least 75% rent-stabilized units made up 19.2%, and affordable housing made up 8.3%, per Connect CRE.

Shimon Shkury, president and founder of Ariel, described a "clear divergence in performance across multifamily property types," Commercial Observer reported. He said free-market buildings and subsidized affordable housing with steady cash flows still draw strong interest. Rent-stabilized buildings, he said, face valuation pressure from regulation and harder financing.

Manhattan Investment Sales: Avison Young's View

Avison Young measured Manhattan third-quarter volume at $2.5 billion, down 27% and the second straight quarterly decline, Commercial Observer reported on October 22, 2026. The borough recorded 87 sales in the quarter.

The full year still looks stronger than 2025. Manhattan deal count rose 22% to 273 through three quarters, and year-to-date volume rose 4% to $9.61 billion. That volume remains below the 10-year average because deal sizes were smaller, Avison Young said.

"We'll have our record year this year, even through all of this," said Brandon Polakoff, principal and head of New York City investment sales at Avison Young, per Commercial Observer. He pointed to a projected decade-high 824 citywide transactions for 2026.

Avison Young's other findings, all reported by Commercial Observer:

  • Office made up nearly half of Manhattan's third-quarter dollar volume.
  • Multifamily year-to-date volume rose 74%, and average price per square foot rose 34%.
  • Retail volume rose 54% from the second quarter, the largest quarterly gain of any asset class.
  • Development volume fell 17% year to date, and average development price per square foot is down nearly half from 2025.
  • Real estate investment trusts (REITs), public companies that own property, took 36% of dollar volume in 2026, up from 7.3% in 2025.
  • International and foreign buyers pulled back.

Polakoff called the development slump "an off quarter, but not an off asset class." He also said higher cap rates have come with higher net operating income, easing pressure on values.

Why Ariel and Avison Young Totals Differ

The two firms count transactions differently, so their totals should not be combined. Ariel puts citywide volume at $23.69 billion through three quarters. Avison Young puts it at $16.2 billion, up 13%, per Commercial Observer.

Each firm uses its own methodology for which trades it counts, and neither report reconciles the two totals. The direction is the more useful comparison. Both firms show more deals in 2026 than in 2025 and a softer third quarter for dollar volume.

Implications for Investors, Owners and Developers

Rising deal counts alongside falling dollar volume point to an active middle market. Smaller private buyers are closing deals, while the largest trades wait for better pricing or financing. Ariel's average deal size fell to about $11.0 million from about $14.8 million a year earlier, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis.

That calculation divides each quarter's dollar volume by its transaction count. The 2025 inputs were backed out of Ariel's reported year-over-year changes.

For owners of Manhattan office, the data fits a market where leasing has improved. Our coverage of the Manhattan office vacancy rate falling to 12.6% and SL Green's third-quarter earnings and tenant incentives shows the same trend. Office still made up 22.0% of Ariel's citywide volume.

The development data deserves attention. Avison Young reported land prices per square foot down nearly half from 2025, while Ariel showed development volume up 9.7% citywide. Lower land basis can help new projects pencil, though rates remain a hurdle.

For a national view of repricing, see our report on distressed commercial real estate sales. MIG covers urban assets on its commercial real estate sector page.

What to Watch in the Fourth Quarter

Ariel said full-year growth depends on the fourth quarter matching the $13.91 billion posted in the fourth quarter of 2025. That outcome hinges on large office and land trades closing, per Ariel Property Advisors.

"We expect fourth-quarter volume to rebound," Ariel's multifamily report stated, per Commercial Observer. Ariel said contracts that stalled during summer rate swings are moving to close before year-end.

Interest rates remain the principal variable. Ariel flagged a 5% 10-year Treasury yield as a higher bar for refinancing and leveraged purchases. It also said investors should watch whether a September slowdown in securitized lending continues.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is real estate investment sales?

Investment sales are purchases of income-producing or development property, such as apartment buildings, offices and land, by investors. Brokers such as Ariel Property Advisors track these trades by dollar volume and deal count. In New York City, they totaled $23.69 billion in the first three quarters of 2026.

Are investment sales in NYC up or down in 2026?

The answer depends on the period measured. Ariel reported year-to-date volume up 9%, but third-quarter volume down 25.2% from 2025. Avison Young found Manhattan third-quarter volume down 27%, with year-to-date volume up 4%, per Commercial Observer.

What does Avison Young say about NYC investment sales?

Avison Young projects a decade-high 824 citywide transactions in 2026 and reported citywide volume up 13% to $16.2 billion through three quarters. Its Manhattan data showed REITs taking 36% of dollar volume, per Commercial Observer.

Key Takeaways

  • New York City investment sales fell 25.2% to $6.73 billion in the third quarter of 2026, while deal count rose 0.7%, Ariel Property Advisors reported.
  • Excluding trades of $250 million or more, third-quarter volume rose 4.0%, pointing to a market missing its largest deals rather than its buyers.
  • Brooklyn led multifamily sales with $693.8 million, ahead of Manhattan below 96th Street at $685.2 million.

Bottom Line

The third quarter of 2026 was the weakest of the year for New York City dollar volume, but not for activity. Deal counts are up at both Ariel and Avison Young, and multifamily, retail and special purpose properties are drawing capital. Whether 2026 sets a record depends on large office and land trades closing in the fourth quarter.

Image credit: Photo by Michael Moloney on Unsplash.

Sources

Disclaimer: This article is for general information and education only. It is not investment, financial, legal, tax or accounting advice, and it is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or property. Morabito Investment Group does not guarantee that the information is complete, accurate or current. Figures, forecasts and opinions from third parties belong to their sources. All investments carry risk, including loss of principal, and past results do not guarantee future results. Do your own research and consult a licensed professional before making any investment, financing or other decision. You use this information at your own risk.

Read more articles