No items found.

Hottest Housing Markets 2026: Appleton No. 1 as 19 of Top 20 Are Midwest, Northeast

Article details
Published:
October 30, 2026
Updated:
Read length:
8
 mins

Appleton, Wis., ranked No. 1 among the hottest housing markets of 2026 in the Wall Street Journal/Realtor.com Fall 2026 ranking released October 29, 2026, with 19 of the top 20 in the Midwest and Northeast.

The quarterly ranking scores the 200 most populous U.S. metros on housing conditions, the local economy and quality of life, Realtor.com said in its release. Lynchburg, Va., at No. 20 is the only top 20 market outside those two regions.

By the Numbers

  • Appleton's median listing price was $404,950 in September 2026, up 1.3% from a year earlier and below the national median of $419,250 (Realtor.com).
  • Active listings in Appleton rose 104.4% year over year to 695 homes (Realtor.com).
  • Top 20 homes sold in an average of 41 days in September, versus a 61 day national average (PR Newswire).
  • The typical monthly principal and interest payment was below the national level of $2,863 in 15 of the top 20 markets (PR Newswire).
  • Prices rose year over year in 11 of the 20 markets while the national median listing price fell 1.4% (Realtor.com).

The Fall 2026 Top 20 Housing Markets

The top ten, in order, are Appleton, Wis.; South Bend, Ind.; Canton, Ohio; Manchester, N.H.; Lancaster, Pa.; Waterbury, Conn.; Reading, Pa.; Fort Wayne, Ind.; Rockford, Ill.; and Harrisburg, Pa.

The release lists the second ten as Springfield, Mass.; Springfield, Mo.; Grand Rapids, Mich.; Portland, Maine; and Bridgeport, Conn. They are followed by Kalamazoo, Mich.; York, Pa.; Hartford, Conn.; Norwich, Conn.; and Lynchburg, Va.

Fourteen of the 20 also made the summer 2026 top 20, Realtor.com reported. Appleton moved up from No. 2, and South Bend slipped from No. 1 to No. 2. Fort Wayne gained nine spots, and Lynchburg fell 12 spots from No. 8.

Six markets are new to the top tier. Bridgeport made the largest jump, climbing 33 spots to No. 15, followed by Portland, Maine, up 32 spots to No. 14, and Waterbury, up 26 spots to No. 6. Grand Rapids, Kalamazoo and Hartford rounded out the newcomers.

Six summer leaders dropped out. Youngstown, Ohio, fell the furthest, from No. 16 to No. 56. Milwaukee slid from No. 12 to No. 21, and Akron, Ohio, fell from No. 10 to No. 23, according to Realtor.com.

Why Appleton Ranked No. 1

"Appleton's top ranking reflects a broad set of strengths rather than one standout metric," Hannah Jones, senior economist at Realtor.com, said in the release. She pointed to a strong local economy, lower housing and living costs, steady demand, improving inventory and a high quality of life.

At roughly 250,000 residents, Appleton is the smallest metro in the top 20. Its 2.8% unemployment rate sits well below the 4.2% average across ranked metros, and its cost of living runs about 8% below the national average, Realtor.com said.

Supply is improving, with Appleton's active listings now just 8.7% below pre-pandemic levels. Homes there spent 40 days on the market in September, about three weeks less than the national norm, Scotsman Guide reported. New listings, however, fell 6.1% from a year earlier to 244, per Realtor.com.

Prices have climbed sharply over time. Appleton's median listing price is 52.5% above 2019, and its price per square foot is 71.7% higher, Realtor.com data show.

Demand comes from well beyond the metro. Only 28.1% of listing views came from inside Appleton, and Chicago accounted for 27.2% of outside views, followed by Milwaukee at 11.0%, Realtor.com found. The report contrasted that with Indianapolis, Kansas City and Cincinnati, where roughly half of views are local.

The report also flagged trade-offs. Wages sit below the 200-metro median, and property taxes take a bigger bite relative to home values than in most ranked markets. On the other hand, Appleton ranked fourth lowest for climate risk.

Where Buyers Still Find Affordable Payments

Realtor.com used a 7.40% 30-year fixed rate in the ranking, up from 6.27% a year earlier. It said the higher rate alone lifts the typical payment by 12.2% at steady prices. Freddie Mac's weekly survey put the 30-year average lower, at 7.24% as of October 29, 2026, down from 7.32% a week earlier, according to Freddie Mac.

Realtor.com's payment figures assume a 7.4% rate and a 13.7% down payment on September median listing prices. On that basis, payments ran as low as $1,820 in Canton, $1,834 in Rockford and $2,202 in South Bend. Canton's payment was 36.4% below the national level, while Appleton's was only 3.4% below.

Several coastal Northeast markets made the list despite high costs. The typical payment was $5,299 in Bridgeport, $4,268 in Portland, Maine, and $3,960 in Manchester, per Realtor.com. Those metros scored on demand and proximity to New York and Boston rather than price.

Affordability is still slipping in the top markets. Prices in the typical top 20 market rose about 1.1% over the past year. Combined with higher rates, that equals a payment increase of about 13.5%, versus about 10.6% nationally, Realtor.com estimated.

Morabito Investment Group Analysis: Two States Hold 8 of the Top 20

Pennsylvania and Connecticut together hold 8 of the 20 top spots, or 40%, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of the Realtor.com ranking tables. Each state has four metros on the list, and only 12 states are represented in total.

Pennsylvania's four are Lancaster, Reading, Harrisburg and York. Connecticut's four are Waterbury, Bridgeport, Hartford and Norwich, and three of those were new to the top 20 this fall.

By the same count, 8 metros are in the Midwest and 11 are in the Northeast. The median typical payment across the top 20 was $2,540.50, about 11.3% below the $2,863 national figure. We calculated the median from Realtor.com's metro payment table.

Midwest and Northeast Sellers Keep the Edge

Realtor.com's Market Clock tool put the national market at 4 o'clock in October 2026, which it describes as late balanced territory moving toward buyers. The Midwest stayed solidly seller friendly, and the Northeast had no buyer's markets among the metros analyzed, Scotsman Guide reported.

Price cuts tell the same story. Price reductions appeared on 15.2% of Northeast listings in September, compared with 22.8% in the West and 21.6% in the South, Realtor.com said. Hartford stood out, with just 12.6% of listings cut and the only 12 o'clock reading, the clock's peak seller position.

The top markets are not immune to the slowdown. The top 20 averaged 18.5% of listings with a price cut versus 20.8% nationally, but both time on market and price cuts rose from a year earlier in those metros.

Midsize Metros Draw Buyers Priced Out of Big Cities

The top 20 averaged about 523,000 residents, compared with 1.3 million across all 200 ranked metros, the release said. Only Grand Rapids and Hartford top 1 million people, Scotsman Guide noted.

Many of these metros sit within reach of major job centers. Reading and Lancaster are near Philadelphia, Waterbury is near New York, and Manchester and Portland, Maine, are close to Boston, Realtor.com said.

What the Ranking Means for Real Estate Investors

For investors, the list highlights midsize markets with low unemployment, quick sales and payments below the national level. Those traits can support rental demand when would-be buyers stay on the sidelines. The broader affordability squeeze is covered in our look at the ATTOM home affordability index for the third quarter of 2026.

Single-family rental and build-to-rent operators may watch these metros closely. Seller-friendly conditions and rising local prices can push some households toward renting, though the ranking itself does not measure rents.

The ranking's weighting also matters for underwriting. Property taxes and climate risk each count for 10% of the score, so a high rank partly reflects lower carrying costs and lower exposure to storms and floods.

Investors should weigh the risks too. Inventory is rising and time on market is lengthening even in the top 20, and recent data showed pending home sales falling to a record low in Redfin data. Earlier rate moves are tracked in our post on mortgage rates reaching 7.40% in October 2026.

How the WSJ/Realtor.com Housing Market Ranking Works

The ranking covers the 200 most populous metros and 12 indicators. The real estate market category carries 60% of the score, and economic health and quality of life carry 40%, the methodology states.

Housing inputs are demand (15%), measured by page views per listing, and supply (15%), measured by days on market. Price trend, property taxes and climate risk count for 10% each. Economic inputs include unemployment, wages, living costs, small businesses, commute time and amenities such as coffee shops and gyms.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the hottest housing markets in the US right now?

The Fall 2026 Wall Street Journal/Realtor.com ranking named Appleton, Wis., South Bend, Ind., and Canton, Ohio, as the top three, per the release. Manchester, N.H., and Lancaster, Pa., completed the top five. Nineteen of the top 20 are in the Midwest and Northeast.

Why are Midwest housing markets so hot in 2026?

Realtor.com said the Midwest remains seller friendly because of strong demand and limited supply. Many of its metros pair lower prices with low unemployment, so typical payments stay below the national level, the report said.

How is the WSJ/Realtor.com housing market ranking calculated?

It scores the 200 largest metros on 12 indicators, with 60% weight on the real estate market and 40% on the economy and quality of life. Inputs include listing page views, days on market, price trends, property taxes, climate risk, unemployment and wages, according to Realtor.com.

Key Takeaways

  • Appleton, Wis., ranked No. 1 in the Fall 2026 Wall Street Journal/Realtor.com Housing Market Ranking released October 29, 2026.
  • Pennsylvania and Connecticut hold 8 of the top 20 spots, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of Realtor.com data.
  • Typical payments were below the $2,863 national level in 15 of the 20 top markets, Realtor.com said.

Bottom Line

The fall 2026 list rewards midsize Midwest and Northeast metros where jobs are steady, homes sell quickly and payments still compare well with the national level. For investors tracking the hottest housing markets of 2026, the list is a useful screen, but rising inventory and higher payments mean local underwriting still matters most.

Image credit: Michael Barera, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).

Sources

Disclaimer: This article is for general information and education only. It is not investment, financial, legal, tax or accounting advice, and it is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or property. Morabito Investment Group does not guarantee that the information is complete, accurate or current. Figures, forecasts and opinions from third parties belong to their sources. All investments carry risk, including loss of principal, and past results do not guarantee future results. Do your own research and consult a licensed professional before making any investment, financing or other decision. You use this information at your own risk.

Read more articles