Hidden Costs of Homeownership Hit $16,566 a Year, Up 31.7% in Five Years
The hidden costs of homeownership averaged $16,566 a year in 2026, or about $1,380 a month on top of a mortgage, according to a Zillow and Thumbtack analysis released on October 22, 2026. Those recurring costs cover maintenance, property taxes and homeowners insurance. They are up 31.7% over five years but only 2.8% over the past year, according to Zillow and Thumbtack.
By the Numbers: Hidden Costs of Homeownership in 2026
- $16,566: Average yearly cost of maintenance, property taxes and insurance for a typical U.S. homeowner, according to Zillow and Thumbtack.
- $11,171: Yearly maintenance, the largest single line, according to Zillow and Thumbtack.
- 54%: Five-year rise in homeowners insurance premiums, the fastest of the three costs, according to Fox Business.
- 19 of 30: Metros where insurance rose at least 50% in five years, led by Dallas at 75%, according to Zillow and Thumbtack.
- $25,111: New York's yearly total, the highest of the 30 metros, compared with $14,187 in Phoenix, according to Zillow and Thumbtack.
What the Zillow and Thumbtack Report Found
Zillow estimated property taxes and homeowners insurance for a typical homeowner in each metro. Thumbtack supplied the maintenance estimate, based on projects requested on its platform and reported by pros or customers. The maintenance figure is a weighted index of yearly projects, calculated quarterly with a moving average, according to Zillow and Thumbtack.
Nationally, the typical owner faces $11,171 in maintenance, $3,129 in property taxes and $2,266 in insurance each year, according to Fox Business. Those three categories add up to the $16,566 total, and none of them includes the mortgage payment itself.
Maintenance makes up 67.4% of the total, insurance 13.7% and property taxes 18.9%, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of the Zillow and Thumbtack figures. We divided each line by the $16,566 total. The report itself describes maintenance as roughly two-thirds of the national bill, according to StockTitan, which carried the full release.
The Hidden Costs of Homeownership Are Skyrocketing, but Growth Is Slowing
Over five years, insurance premiums rose 54%, maintenance 32% and property taxes 19%, according to Fox Business. The overall bill rose 31.7% in five years, according to Zillow and Thumbtack. That implies a total of about $12,580 five years ago, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis that divides $16,566 by 1.317.
The past year looked considerably calmer, with total costs rising 2.8%, a figure Fox Business rounded to 3%. Yearly maintenance increases shrank every year, from 9% in 2022 to 1% in 2026, according to Zillow and Thumbtack.
Insurance growth also moderated during 2026. Federal data showed premiums rose just 0.3% between February and June 2026, according to Zillow and Thumbtack. Premiums still sit well above where they were five years earlier.
"Many households focus so much on winning the home and underestimate what it costs to live in it," Kara Ng, a Zillow senior economist, said in the release. "Long after they receive the keys, insurance, taxes and upkeep are recurring expenses to plan for," she added, according to StockTitan.
Homeowners Insurance Is the Fastest-Growing Line
Insurance premiums rose at least 50% over five years in 19 of the 30 metros studied. Dallas led at 75%, followed by Tampa at 71%, Denver at 70% and Houston at 69%, according to Fox Business. The report points to severe weather, such as hail, tornadoes and damaging winds, as a likely driver in storm-prone areas.
Miami homeowners pay the most for insurance, at nearly $5,000 a year. Six metros top $3,000: Miami, Dallas, Houston, Tampa, Orlando and Denver, according to Zillow and Thumbtack.
In four metros, insurance now costs more than property taxes. Homeowners in Houston, Phoenix, Denver and Nashville pay more each year to insure a home than to tax it, according to StockTitan.
Maintenance Costs by Metro
Maintenance is the largest hidden cost in every metro studied. It tops $12,000 a year in six major metros, including Seattle at $12,594 and Boston at $12,486, according to Fox Business.
Los Angeles posted the sharpest jump, with maintenance up 27% in one year. The report ties that rise to wildfire recovery, strong demand for home services and high labor costs, according to Zillow and Thumbtack.
"The slowdown in maintenance cost growth is welcome news for homeowners managing a lot of competing expenses," said Kendra Sinclair, Thumbtack's home trends expert, according to Fox Business.
Hidden Costs of Owning a Home in the Most and Least Expensive Metros
The highest yearly totals are in coastal markets, according to the metro table published by Zillow and Thumbtack:
- New York: $25,111, up 1.8% in a year and 13.8% in five years.
- San Francisco: $24,383, up 3.4% in a year and 28.9% in five years.
- Los Angeles: $22,915, up 15.9% in a year and 42.5% in five years.
- Boston: $22,096, up 2.8% in a year and 27.1% in five years.
- Phoenix: $14,187, the lowest of the 30 metros, up 5.3% in a year.
New York's yearly total is $10,924 above Phoenix's, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of the Zillow and Thumbtack table.
The biggest five-year increase belongs to Pittsburgh, at 54.8%. Tampa rose 44.4% and Miami 42.8% over the same span, according to Zillow and Thumbtack. Atlanta and Seattle were the only metros where the total fell over the past year, by 2.5% and 1.5%.
What It Means for Rental and Build-to-Rent Investors
These are the same carrying costs that single-family rental and build-to-rent owners pay, because a landlord does not avoid insurance, taxes or upkeep by renting the home out. The Zillow and Thumbtack data gives investors a metro-by-metro check on their operating budgets.
Insurance is the line most likely to surprise an underwriting model in the Sun Belt. Dallas, Houston, Tampa and Denver each saw premiums climb roughly 70% or more in five years, according to Fox Business. Owners who underwrote those markets in 2021 may be carrying expense loads well above their original plans.
For a wider look at commercial coverage, see our report on commercial property insurance rates in 2026. That report covers large commercial policies, a separate market from the homeowner premiums in this study.
Maintenance reserves matter too, since maintenance represents about two-thirds of the typical annual bill. The report notes that new construction often needs fewer near-term repairs, according to Zillow and Thumbtack. That point is relevant to build-to-rent communities, where homes start new.
Higher ownership costs also influence rental demand. When owning costs about $1,380 a month before the mortgage, some households may find renting easier to budget. Our coverage of the ATTOM Home Affordability Index for the third quarter of 2026 shows how stretched buyers already are.
Property taxes are the slowest-growing line in this study, yet they still strain some owners. See our report on property tax delinquency rising to its highest level since 2017 for more on that trend.
What to Watch
- Whether insurance premiums stay near the flat reading seen from February to June 2026, or resume their climb after storm seasons.
- Whether maintenance growth holds near 1%, as labor and materials costs move.
- Whether Los Angeles maintenance costs settle as wildfire recovery work slows.
- How property tax reassessments track home values in high-growth metros.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the hidden costs of owning a home?
The Zillow and Thumbtack study counts three recurring costs beyond the mortgage: maintenance, property taxes and homeowners insurance. Together they averaged $16,566 a year in 2026, according to Zillow and Thumbtack. Maintenance was the largest piece at $11,171.
Are the hidden costs of homeownership skyrocketing?
They rose 31.7% over five years, led by a 54% jump in insurance, according to Zillow and Thumbtack. Growth slowed to 2.8% over the past year, however. Maintenance increases fell from 9% in 2022 to 1% in 2026.
Which metro has the highest hidden costs of buying a home?
New York has the highest yearly total at $25,111, followed by San Francisco at $24,383, according to Zillow and Thumbtack. Phoenix has the lowest at $14,187.
Key Takeaways
- The hidden costs of homeownership averaged $16,566 a year in 2026, about $1,380 a month beyond the mortgage, according to Zillow and Thumbtack.
- Homeowners insurance rose 54% in five years, and premiums climbed at least 50% in 19 of 30 metros.
- Maintenance makes up 67.4% of the total, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of the Zillow and Thumbtack figures.
Bottom Line
The recurring expense of maintaining a home has grown considerably over five years, even as annual growth moderated in 2026. For investors in single-family rentals and build-to-rent, the study is a reminder that insurance and upkeep can move returns as much as rent. Metropolitan-level data like this is a useful input for operating budgets and underwriting assumptions.
Image credit: Photo by Ian MacDonald on Unsplash.
Sources
- Zillow Group and Thumbtack (PR Newswire), "Hidden costs of homeownership top $16.5K a year, up nearly 32% in 5 years," https://zillow.mediaroom.com/2026-10-22-Hidden-costs-of-homeownership-top-16-5K-year,-up-nearly-32-in-5-years
- Fox Business, "Owning a home comes with a hidden price tag, and it's getting more expensive," https://www.foxbusiness.com/economy/owning-home-comes-hidden-price-tag-its-getting-more-expensive
- StockTitan, "Hidden costs of homeownership top $16.5K a year, up nearly 32% in 5 years," https://www.stocktitan.net/news/Z/hidden-costs-of-homeownership-top-16-5k-year-up-nearly-32-in-5-hsqmt0ni0m8y.html
Disclaimer: This article is for general information and education only. It is not investment, financial, legal, tax or accounting advice, and it is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or property. Morabito Investment Group does not guarantee that the information is complete, accurate or current. Figures, forecasts and opinions from third parties belong to their sources. All investments carry risk, including loss of principal, and past results do not guarantee future results. Do your own research and consult a licensed professional before making any investment, financing or other decision. You use this information at your own risk.
This article is for general information only. It is not legal, tax, financial, or investment advice, and it is not an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security. Talk to your own advisors before acting on anything in it. Views are current as of the publish date and may change without notice.








