No items found.

Cost to Buy a Home Runs 85.3% Above Current Mortgages, Realtor.com Finds

Article details
Published:
November 11, 2026
Updated:
Read length:
7
 mins

The cost to buy a home would run the typical U.S. mortgage holder about $1,100 more a month than their current loan, a jump from $1,332 to $2,468, Realtor.com reported on November 11, 2026.

That 85.3% increase covers principal and interest only, according to Realtor.com via PR Newswire. It would also lift the share of income the typical household spends on housing by 15.6 percentage points. The study compares what current owners pay with what the same owners would pay to buy a median-priced home today.

This is a new and separate Realtor.com report. It is not the second-quarter rate data covered in our earlier post on the mortgage lock-in effect in Q2 2026. That post tracked the share of loans below 6%, while this study puts a dollar figure on the cost of moving.

By the Numbers: The Cost to Buy a Home vs. Today's Mortgages

  • $1,332 vs. $2,468: typical current monthly principal and interest payment vs. the estimated payment to buy a median-priced home, an 85.3% gap (Realtor.com via PR Newswire).
  • About 4.0% vs. 7.32%: the rate on the typical outstanding mortgage vs. the rate the report used to model a purchase today (Realtor.com via PR Newswire).
  • Roughly one-third: share of the 100 largest metros where buying would more than double the typical owner's payment (Realtor.com via PR Newswire).
  • 167.0%: the largest increase, in Portland, Maine, where the payment would rise from $1,270 to $3,392 (Realtor.com via PR Newswire).
  • 43.3%: the smallest increase, in Pittsburgh, where the payment would rise from $1,005 to $1,441 (Realtor.com via PR Newswire).
  • $419,250: the September 2026 national median listing price used in the model, with a 14.3% down payment (Realtor.com).

What the 7.32% Rate in the Report Means

The 7.32% figure is an assumption, not a forecast. Realtor.com used the Freddie Mac weekly average as of October 22, 2026, to price a new 30-year fixed loan, according to the report methodology. Rates move every week, so the dollar gap will shift with them.

Each payment in the study excludes property taxes and insurance, the methodology states. Current payments come from Optimal Blue data on fixed-rate, owner-occupied loans made since 2013. Those loans were weighted to match the age mix of outstanding mortgages in the FHFA National Mortgage Database for the second quarter of 2026.

The new payment uses each metro's September 2026 median listing price and its typical down payment share. Realtor.com also notes that this edition uses an updated method, so its figures are not directly comparable with the December 2025 report (Realtor.com).

Where the Cost to Buy a Home Jumps the Most

High-priced coastal metros with low existing rates show the steepest jumps. In San Jose, the payment to buy would reach $7,039 a month, up 164.8% from $2,659, even with a typical down payment of 26.2% (Realtor.com via PR Newswire). In Los Angeles, it would rise from $2,149 to $5,628, or 161.9%.

Oxnard, Calif., and Albany, N.Y., round out the top five, each with an increase above 140% (Realtor.com via PR Newswire). Bridgeport, Conn., Providence, R.I., and Boise, Idaho, also rank among the ten largest gaps in the Realtor.com table.

Larger loan balances magnify higher rates in expensive markets, Realtor.com economists said. A homeowner trading an older, low-rate loan for a new one can face a steep payment jump, which makes a move within the same metro harder (Realtor.com via PR Newswire).

The Least Locked-In Markets Are in the Midwest and South

Pittsburgh posts the smallest gap among the 100 largest metros at 43.3% (Realtor.com via PR Newswire). Baltimore follows at 45.0%, and Buffalo, N.Y., comes next at 46.1%. New Orleans, Detroit and Birmingham, Ala., also sit below 60%.

Lower prices help, but so do higher existing rates. Roughly 75% of mortgages in the South and Midwest carry a rate below 6%, compared with 77.5% nationally, according to the Realtor.com report. That share is 82.3% in the West.

"More affordable markets offer homeowners a smaller payment jump, not an escape from higher costs," said Hannah Jones, senior economist at Realtor.com (Realtor.com via PR Newswire). San Antonio shows a third factor at work: its median listing price was $320,374 in September, down 2.9% from a year earlier, and its gap is 60.8%.

Buffalo shows what lower lock-in can look like on the ground. It posted the largest year-over-year rise in active listings among the 50 largest metros in October 2026, up 34.4%, according to Realtor.com News.

Morabito Investment Group Analysis: How Wide the Gap Runs

The national gap works out to $1,136 a month, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of the Realtor.com data, calculated as $2,468 minus $1,332. In Portland, Maine, the new payment would be 2.67 times the current one ($3,392 divided by $1,270).

Our count of the full 100-metro table finds 31 metros where the gap tops 100%. That matches Realtor.com's description of roughly one-third. The median gap across those 100 metros is 89.9%, a bit above the national figure of 85.3%.

The split is regional. Seven of the 10 California metros in the table would more than double. Only two of the 16 Texas and Florida metros would, El Paso at 110.8% and Port Saint Lucie at 100.4%.

Mortgage Lock-In Effect: What Lower Rates Would and Would Not Fix

Lower rates would narrow the gap but not close it. Each half-point drop lowers the national payment by about $110 to $120 and trims the gap by about 8 to 9 percentage points, Realtor.com estimated (Realtor.com via PR Newswire).

At a 6.0% rate, the payment would be $2,154, still 61.7% above what the typical owner pays (Realtor.com via PR Newswire). Only at that level could just over half of households, 50.2%, afford the median-priced home, assuming principal and interest take no more than 30% of income.

Even a 4.0% rate would leave the payment about 29% higher, because prices have climbed since most current loans were made (Realtor.com via PR Newswire). "Lower rates alone would not erase the affordability gap," Jones said. These are scenarios in the report, not rate forecasts.

The payment gap adds to a broader affordability squeeze that Realtor.com has also tracked by state, as covered in our post on housing affordability by state in 2026.

What It Means for Investors, Owners and Developers

Thin resale supply is the first effect. When owners stay put, fewer homes are listed, and existing-home sales have hovered near 4 million a year since 2023, according to Realtor.com. Most sales now come from need-to-move events such as a new job, marriage or divorce.

Many owners hold large equity stakes but face a steep payment to trade up. Our recent post on ICE data on homeowner equity and equity millionaires shows how much value is tied up in homes that are not changing hands.

For rental housing, a wide gap means would-be first-time buyers face a higher bar to leave renting. That can support demand for single-family rentals and build-to-rent communities in the most locked-in metros, though local rents, supply and wages still decide results.

New-home builders face the same rate math as resale buyers, but in the markets with the largest gaps they may face less competition from existing listings. In markets like Pittsburgh or San Antonio, where gaps are smaller, more owners can move and resale inventory may compete harder.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to buy a home compared with a current mortgage?

The typical U.S. mortgage holder pays $1,332 a month in principal and interest, while buying a median-priced home would cost about $2,468, according to Realtor.com via PR Newswire. That is an 85.3% increase, before taxes and insurance.

What is the mortgage lock-in effect?

It describes owners who stay in their homes because moving would mean trading a low-rate loan for a costlier one. The typical outstanding loan carries a rate of about 4.0%, compared with the 7.32% rate the report used to price a purchase (Realtor.com via PR Newswire).

Is the mortgage lock-in effect fading?

Slowly, according to Realtor.com. The share of outstanding mortgages below 6% slipped from 79.8% to 77.5% over the past year, and the share below 3% fell from 20.2% to 19.2% (Realtor.com). The report calls this a sign that unlocking is happening, but slowly.

Key Takeaways

  • The cost to buy a home is $1,136 a month above the typical owner's current payment, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of Realtor.com data.
  • Portland, Maine, has the widest gap at 167.0%, while Pittsburgh has the narrowest at 43.3%, Realtor.com reported on November 11, 2026.
  • Even at a 6.0% rate, buying would still cost 61.7% more than the typical current payment, according to Realtor.com.

Bottom Line

Realtor.com's November 11, 2026, report puts a price on staying put: about $1,100 a month for the typical owner. The gap is widest on the coasts and narrowest in lower-cost Midwest and Southern metros. For investors, that map points to where resale supply is likely to stay tight and where housing turnover is more active.

Image credit: AlexiusHoratius (CC BY-SA 3.0), via Wikimedia Commons.

Sources

Disclaimer: This article is for general information and education only. It is not investment, financial, legal, tax or accounting advice, and it is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or property. Morabito Investment Group does not guarantee that the information is complete, accurate or current. Figures, forecasts and opinions from third parties belong to their sources. All investments carry risk, including loss of principal, and past results do not guarantee future results. Do your own research and consult a licensed professional before making any investment, financing or other decision. You use this information at your own risk.

Read more articles