Commercial Real Estate Sentiment Falls to 48, First Negative Reading Since 2023
Commercial real estate sentiment fell to 48 in September 2026 from 52 in March, the first reading below 50 since September 2023, the Commercial Real Estate Development Association (CREDA) said on October 15, 2026. CREDA, formerly known as NAIOP, said worries about interest rates and construction costs drove the drop, Connect CRE reported.
A score below 50 means respondents expect conditions to worsen over the next 12 months. The survey also found that property-level performance is holding up. That split between weak development sentiment and steady fundamentals is the main signal for investors.
By the Numbers
- 48: the CRE Sentiment Index in September 2026, down from 52 in March, per Scotsman Guide.
- 46: the last reading below 50, in September 2023, per Scotsman Guide.
- 31: the interest rate score, down from 52, the largest drop between surveys since April 2022, per Connect CRE.
- 27 and 30: the construction materials and labor cost scores, down from 37 and 35, per Scotsman Guide.
- 39.7%: the share of respondents naming industrial as the most active property type for the next 12 months, per Scotsman Guide.
What the CREDA Sentiment Index Measured in Fall 2026
CREDA publishes the index twice a year. It asks developers, owners and other industry professionals to forecast conditions for their own projects and markets over the next 12 months, according to CREDA. A reading of 50 is the break-even line between better and worse conditions.
The fall 2026 survey drew 401 respondents and ran from September 15 to 23, 2026, Connect CRE reported. The overall score fell 4 points in six months. That move took the index from mildly positive to mildly negative.
CREDA described the result as an expectation that conditions will worsen slightly, not sharply, according to its index page. Investors should read 48 as caution, not alarm.
Interest Rates and Construction Costs Drive the Drop
The interest rate score fell 21 points, from 52 in March to 31 in September. Scotsman Guide said that was the largest decline between surveys since April 2022, when the Federal Reserve moved to a more restrictive policy. Respondents also expect equity and debt to be slightly harder to get and first-year cap rates to rise.
A cap rate, or capitalization rate, is a property's first-year net operating income divided by its price. Higher expected cap rates mean buyers expect to pay less for each dollar of income. That points to softer pricing for new deals.
Cost worries rose too. The construction materials score fell 10 points to 27, and the labor cost score fell 5 points to 30, the most pessimistic readings since April 2022, per Scotsman Guide. CREDA said cost increases are coming faster than respondents expected in March, according to its index page.
Some respondents explained their views. One linked higher oil prices to rising construction costs, Scotsman Guide reported. Another cited tariff threats affecting industrial leasing and the chance of more Fed rate hikes, calling it "uncertainty that keeps equity on the sidelines."
Property Fundamentals Still Look Strong
Not every measure weakened. Respondents expect occupancy to rise and rents to grow faster than they expected in March, according to Scotsman Guide. They also expect higher dollar volume of transactions and projects and slight job growth at their own firms.
The separate general industry conditions score was 51, which is positive. CREDA suggested that may reflect optimism about existing assets rather than new development, or about factors the index does not measure, such as the broader economy, per Scotsman Guide.
"This fall, respondents are telling us that property-level performance remains strong, while uncertainty around capital markets, costs and policy is shaping when and where new development makes sense," said Marc Selvitelli, CREDA president and CEO, according to Connect CRE. CREDA concluded that current conditions favor stabilized properties over new development.
Industrial Leads Expected Activity by Property Type
Respondents named the property types they expect to be most active over the next 12 months, per Scotsman Guide:
- Industrial: 39.7%
- Multifamily: 19.7%
- Data centers: 11.5%
- Retail: 9.7%
- Office: 7.2%
- Mixed-use: 4.5%
Industrial drew about twice the share of multifamily, the second choice. Together, industrial and data centers account for 51.2% of responses, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of the Scotsman Guide figures. That fits recent industrial results, including Prologis's third quarter 2026 earnings, where the CEO said new builds need higher rents to pencil.
How This Differs From CREFC Lender Sentiment
The CREDA index is a developer and owner survey. It is separate from the CRE Finance Council (CREFC) Board of Governors index, which tracks lenders and other finance executives. CREFC's index fell 17.5% to 83.3 in the third quarter of 2026 from 101.0, a three-year low, CRE Daily reported.
We covered the lender side in our post on the CMBS delinquency rate and CRE credit stress. Both surveys now point the same way. Developers and lenders each expect a tougher year for new capital.
The Federal Reserve's October 2026 survey of regional business contacts also found tighter commercial real estate credit. See our summary of the October 2026 Beige Book on housing and commercial real estate.
What Commercial Real Estate Sentiment Means for Investors
When developers turn cautious while fundamentals hold, fewer new projects tend to start. Less new supply can support occupancy and rents at existing buildings. The CREDA survey points to that pattern: weaker views on costs and financing, stronger views on rents and occupancy.
For owners of stabilized assets, steady demand and slower new supply can be a support. For developers, higher rates and costs raise the rent a new project needs to work. Projects with a committed tenant before construction, known as build-to-suit development, carry less leasing risk than speculative starts.
Capital costs remain the key variable. If rates stay high, expected cap rate increases could weigh on values even as rents grow. These are the dynamics each investor should weigh against their own goals and risk tolerance.
What to Watch
- CREDA's next index, expected in spring 2027 based on its twice-yearly schedule.
- Whether rents and occupancy rise as respondents expect.
- Construction cost data for materials and labor.
- Lender surveys such as CREFC's for signs that credit is easing or tightening further.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the current sentiment of the commercial real estate market?
Developer and owner sentiment turned slightly negative in fall 2026. CREDA's index fell to 48 in September from 52 in March, according to Scotsman Guide. Respondents still expect stronger occupancy and rent growth.
Why did commercial real estate sentiment fall in 2026?
Interest rates and construction costs drove the decline, per Connect CRE. The interest rate score fell to 31 from 52. Materials and labor cost scores hit their lowest levels since April 2022.
Do property fundamentals or investor sentiment matter more for valuation?
Both matter, and in fall 2026 they diverged. CREDA respondents expect better rents and occupancy but also higher cap rates, according to Scotsman Guide. Higher cap rates lower the price paid for the same income.
Key Takeaways
- CREDA's CRE Sentiment Index fell to 48 in September 2026, its first reading below 50 since September 2023.
- The interest rate score fell 21 points to 31, the largest drop between surveys since April 2022.
- Industrial led expected activity at 39.7% of respondents, and CREDA said conditions favor stabilized properties over new development.
Bottom Line
Developers are more cautious about financing and costs than at any point since 2022, while their outlook for rents and occupancy improved. That gap favors existing, leased buildings over speculative construction for now. The spring 2027 survey will show whether the caution holds.
Image credit: Photo by Kouji Tsuru on Unsplash.
Sources
- Connect CRE, CREDA Sentiment Index Declines on Interest Rates, Construction Costs: https://www.connectcre.com/stories/creda-sentiment-index-declines-on-interest-rates-construction-costs/
- Scotsman Guide, Commercial real estate sentiment turns negative for the first time since 2023: https://www.scotsmanguide.com/news/commercial-real-estate-sentiment-turns-negative-for-first-time-since-2023/
- CREDA, CRE Sentiment Index: https://www.credaglobal.org/sentimentindex
- CRE Daily, CREFC Sentiment Index Falls 17.5% to Three-Year Low: https://www.credaily.com/briefs/crefc-sentiment-index-falls-17-5-to-three-year-low/
Disclaimer: This article is for general information and education only. It is not investment, financial, legal, tax or accounting advice, and it is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or property. Morabito Investment Group does not guarantee that the information is complete, accurate or current. Figures, forecasts and opinions from third parties belong to their sources. All investments carry risk, including loss of principal, and past results do not guarantee future results. Do your own research and consult a licensed professional before making any investment, financing or other decision. You use this information at your own risk.
This article is for general information only. It is not legal, tax, financial, or investment advice, and it is not an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security. Talk to your own advisors before acting on anything in it. Views are current as of the publish date and may change without notice.








