CMBS Loan Modifications Near $100B as 21.3% of Modified Debt Turns Delinquent
Servicers have modified 966 commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) loans worth $98.3 billion since 2022, and 21.3% of the $49.8 billion still outstanding is delinquent again, Trepp reported on November 18, 2026.
CMBS loan modifications were meant to give struggling borrowers time to recover. The data now shows that time alone has fixed few of these loans, which matters for lenders, bondholders, and anyone buying commercial property debt.
By the Numbers
- Modified since January 2022: 966 loans with $98.3 billion of balance (Trepp).
- Delinquency of modified debt still outstanding: 21.3%, versus 4.7% for loans never modified (Trepp).
- Share of the CMBS market: modified loans are 7.3% of outstanding balance, up from 1.3% at the end of 2022 (Bisnow).
- Busiest year: 2025, with 281 loans and $28.4 billion modified (Trepp).
- Paydown effect: 21% of loans with a paydown were in trouble 12 months later, versus 40% without one (Trepp).
CMBS loan modifications keep growing but do not always hold
A modification changes a loan's terms after a borrower falls behind.
Most of them buy time. Trepp found that 61% of modifications since 2022 extended the maturity, and the typical extension was 12 months. Forbearance agreements, which pause or reduce payments, made up 24%.
Through October, 2026 added 141 loans and $17.4 billion. That count will rise as late reports arrive, although 2026 is currently on pace for fewer modifications than 2025 because special servicers are modifying less.
Of the $49.8 billion of modified debt still outstanding, 21.3% is delinquent. According to a Morabito Investment Group calculation from Trepp's figures, that is about $10.6 billion of loans that were modified and have fallen behind again. About 41% of the modified balance is with a special servicer.
Trepp analysts wrote, as quoted by Bisnow, that "the middle way, a modification that buys time, has lost the most ground since 2024."
Where the delinquency is concentrated
The gap between modified and unmodified loans is widest outside office. In retail, 24% of modified balance is delinquent versus 2% of retail loans never modified. In lodging, the split is 26% versus 1%.
Office is weak either way. Trepp found 19% of modified office balance delinquent versus 10% of office loans never modified. Mixed-use is the worst of the major property types at 43%.
Office now leads the modification queue, with 36% of modified balance since 2022, followed by retail at 21%. In 2022, office trailed both lodging and retail. Lodging fell from 31% of modified balance to 8% in 2026.
COVID-era loans look worse. Nearly a third of their balance is delinquent, and 47% is in special servicing, according to Trepp.
Paydowns are the strongest signal
Not every modification asks the borrower for new money. A paydown, meaning the borrower repays part of the principal, came with 22% of modifications since 2022. The typical paydown was 5.4% of the loan balance.
Trepp's second report, published on November 19, 2026, looked at the 210 modifications that included a paydown of at least 1%. Those borrowers paid down $2.0 billion in total.
At 12 months, 21% of them were in special servicing, delinquent, or liquidated, versus 40% of loans without a paydown. At 24 months, the split was 17% versus 39%.
Payers were also more likely to pay off entirely: 51% versus 18%, according to CRE Daily's summary of the Trepp study.
Payers did start from a stronger position, and their typical debt service coverage ratio (DSCR), the cash flow cushion lenders require, was 1.69x versus 1.44x. Their loan-to-value ratio was 54% versus 59%.
Even so, Trepp found that payers performed better in every DSCR band and every loan-to-value band, which suggests that the willingness to write a check carries information beyond credit quality.
Higher reserves told a murkier story. A year later, 29% of loans with higher reserves were in trouble versus 24% of the rest. Trepp says some of those reserves were excess property cash swept after a cash trap, not new borrower money.
What this means for investors, owners, and lenders
For CMBS bondholders, the data suggests extensions by themselves carry real redefault risk. Servicers now lean on other exits. Trepp earlier found that foreclosure accounted for 23% of special servicing exits, while modifications fell to 37% from 54% in 2024, per CRE Daily.
For property owners, a lender is more likely to offer time when it also receives cash. That finding fits the pattern in our coverage of the October CMBS delinquency rate and the special servicing rate.
For equity investors, the mix of modified debt matters. A property whose loan was extended for 12 months still faces the same refinancing math at the end of the term. Our look at bank and mortgage REIT lending shows how the lender landscape is shifting around that problem.
What to watch next
Roughly half of modified debt has matured, according to Bisnow's reading of the Trepp data, while $49.8 billion remains. The next test is how many of the remaining loans can refinance at maturity. Servicer behavior will also matter, because master servicers now handle a growing share of modifications.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a CMBS loan modification?
It is a change to a loan's terms, such as a longer maturity, lower payments, or added reserves, agreed by a servicer and borrower. Trepp counted 966 of them with $98.3 billion of balance since 2022 (Trepp).
How many modified CMBS loans become delinquent again?
Of the $49.8 billion modified since 2022 and still outstanding, 21.3% is delinquent. That is more than four times the 4.7% rate for loans never modified (Trepp).
Do paydowns help a CMBS modification work?
In Trepp's data, borrowers who paid down were about half as likely to be in trouble two years later. The study notes they started with stronger credit, but they did better in every DSCR and LTV band (Trepp).
Key Takeaways
- About one in five modified CMBS dollars still outstanding is delinquent again, at 21.3%.
- Delinquency after modification is highest in mixed-use, lodging, and retail, and still elevated in office.
- Borrowers who paid down principal were about half as likely to be in trouble two years later.
Bottom Line
CMBS loan modifications have become a large part of the market, but extensions alone have not produced durable recoveries. Investors who track commercial real estate debt should watch paydowns, reserves, and servicer choices as signals of which loans are likely to hold.
Image credit: Photo by Mario Gogh on Unsplash.
Sources
- Trepp, Modified, Not Fixed: The State of CMBS Loan Modifications, November 18, 2026
- Trepp, Pay to Stay: What CMBS Borrowers Put In to Win a Modification, November 19, 2026
- Bisnow, Trepp: 20% Of The CMBS Loans Modified Since 2022 Are Delinquent Again
- CRE Daily, CMBS Loan Modifications With Paydowns Fare Twice as Well
Disclaimer: This article is for general information and education only. It is not investment, financial, legal, tax or accounting advice, and it is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or property. Morabito Investment Group does not guarantee that the information is complete, accurate or current. Figures, forecasts and opinions from third parties belong to their sources. All investments carry risk, including loss of principal, and past results do not guarantee future results. Do your own research and consult a licensed professional before making any investment, financing or other decision. You use this information at your own risk.
This article is for general information only. It is not legal, tax, financial, or investment advice, and it is not an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security. Talk to your own advisors before acting on anything in it. Views are current as of the publish date and may change without notice.








