No items found.

Climate Risk Scores Lawsuit: Florida Sues First Street, Seeks $10,000 Per Violation

Article details
Published:
October 28, 2026
Updated:
Read length:
7
 mins

Florida sued climate risk modeler First Street on October 23, 2026, alleging its climate risk scores mislead home buyers and seeking civil penalties of $10,000 per violation, HousingWire reported.

The suit follows a similar Nebraska case filed in August 2026. Both put the scores shown on major listing sites before state courts. Neither court has ruled on the merits.

By the Numbers: The First Street Climate Risk Scores Lawsuits

  • Florida filed its complaint on October 23, 2026, in the Tenth Judicial Circuit Court in Polk County under the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act (Tampa Free Press via AOL).
  • The state seeks civil penalties of $10,000 per violation, or $15,000 where seniors or people with disabilities were affected (HousingWire).
  • First Street rates homes on a 1 to 10 scale for hazards such as flood, wildfire, wind, heat and air quality (Bloomberg via Insurance Journal).
  • Nebraska filed its suit on August 27, 2026, in Dakota County District Court (10/11 NOW via WOWT).
  • MSCI agreed in June 2026 to pay $120 million in cash for First Street, with possible earnout payments (ESG Today), and completed the deal on August 3, 2026 (MSCI).

What Florida Alleges About Climate Risk Scores

The complaint centers on First Street's Risk Factor grades, according to HousingWire. It alleges the company presents the scores as accurate, transparent and scientifically validated without adequately disclosing their uncertainty and limits.

The state says the grades can shape whether people buy a home, how much they offer and what insurance quotes they get. It also alleges owners have no clear way to correct a disputed score. First Street's dispute guidance says it generally does not change scores based on individual disputes, HousingWire reported.

A central claim is a mismatch with federal flood maps. The state says some homes rated major flood risk by First Street are rated minimal flood hazard by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). That is the lowest federal category, according to HousingWire.

One example in the complaint is a home in Oldsmar, Florida. FEMA places it in Zone X, a minimal flood hazard area, while First Street gave it a flood score of 7 out of 10, labeled Major, Tampa Free Press reported.

The complaint also says First Street lists coastal flooding as a risk for Orlando, roughly 45 to 60 miles from the coast. It flags Lake City for air quality concerns as well, according to Florida Phoenix via Creative Loafing Tampa.

The Florida Attorney General's office said in a video that "homeowners deserve facts, not alarmist scores that hit their property values and their wallets," Bloomberg reported. The state also argues that inaccurate scores could affect insurance costs and coverage, since insurers use First Street data.

What Relief the State Is Seeking

Florida asks for a jury trial and a permanent injunction, according to HousingWire. The injunction would bar claims about accuracy that do not disclose uncertainty. It would also bar describing the scores as peer reviewed or transparent.

The state also seeks consumer redress and disgorgement, meaning the return of profits it alleges were improperly earned. The complaint brings two counts under the state's consumer protection law, one for unfair practices and one for deceptive practices, Florida Phoenix reported.

As of October 26, 2026, First Street had not filed a formal response in the Polk County court, according to Tampa Free Press. The allegations have not been proven in court.

The Nebraska Case Filed in August 2026

Nebraska's attorney general sued First Street on August 27, 2026. The state alleges the company's scores often rely on inaccurate or incomplete property data and ignore flood protection that owners have installed, according to 10/11 NOW.

The suit also alleges First Street did not disclose that its predictions may differ from federal data or other models. Nebraska says the scores led some sellers to accept lower offers or wait longer for a sale. It asks the court to halt the practices, impose fines and recover profits.

First Street's Response and Its Stated Methods

First Street and MSCI did not respond to requests for comment on the Florida suit, Bloomberg and HousingWire reported. Florida Phoenix also said it had not received a reply by publication.

The company has described its approach in public before. Its website says FEMA maps assess flood risk at the community level for single 1 in 100 or 1 in 500 year events, Tampa Free Press reported. First Street says its own tool works at the property level and adds changing climate conditions and heavy rainfall.

MSCI describes First Street's work as physics-based climate risk data covering more than 2.4 billion structures worldwide, according to its August 3, 2026, release. In 2025, a First Street spokesperson said "the risk doesn't go away; it just moves from a pre-purchase decision into a post-purchase liability," TechCrunch reported.

How Climate Risk Scores Reach Zillow, Redfin and Realtor.com Users

Zillow, Redfin and Realtor.com began showing First Street scores after its first major report in 2020, according to Bloomberg. As of the morning of October 27, 2026, all three still showed First Street data or linked to it, HousingWire reported.

Zillow removed the scores from more than 1 million listings in late 2025 after the California Regional Multiple Listing Service objected. It replaced them with a link to First Street, according to TechCrunch. HousingWire dates the change to December 2025, while TechCrunch reported it in November.

Views on the data differ. Redfin chief economist Daryl Fairweather wrote on LinkedIn that "homebuyers find climate risk scores valuable," HousingWire reported. In a separate case, a Chappaqua, N.Y., couple sued First Street and Zillow in June 2025 over a flood rating on their listing, and that case is pending.

Researchers have also noted model disagreement. A 2024 Bloomberg comparison found First Street's 2020 Los Angeles flood estimates overlapped an academic team's results only about a quarter of the time, Insurance Journal reported.

Boston University law professor Madison Condon told Bloomberg she has concerns about First Street's marketing. She also warned such suits could discourage sharing climate risk data, adding that "scientific models can disagree without being willfully deceptive."

Morabito Investment Group Analysis: The Sell-Through Gap Cited in the Complaint

The Florida complaint cites a Zillow study finding that 52% of homes with a high flood risk rating eventually sold, compared with 71% of low risk homes, Florida Phoenix reported.

That is a gap of 19 percentage points. High risk homes sold at a rate about 27% lower than low risk homes, according to a Morabito Investment Group analysis of the figures cited in the complaint. The study shows a pattern, not proof that the scores caused it, and it is not a court finding.

What the Climate Risk Scores Lawsuits Mean for Real Estate Investors

For investors, the cases highlight how much one data source can shape pricing and time on market. That matters most in coastal states such as Florida, where insurance rates add to affordability pressure, Bloomberg noted. Our September 2026 Florida housing market report tracks the state's sales trend.

A common diligence step is to compare several risk sources rather than one. Those include FEMA flood zones, flood elevation certificates, actual insurer quotes and private models. Different tools use different methods, as both First Street and its critics describe.

Insurance is the other link. Our coverage of commercial property insurance rates in 2026 and Hurricane Isaias insured losses shows how storm risk feeds into cost assumptions for large-scale residential and other assets.

What to watch next is First Street's formal response in Polk County, any rulings in the Nebraska case, and whether listing portals change how they display the data.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are First Street climate risk scores?

They are 1 to 10 ratings that estimate a property's exposure to flood, wildfire, heat, wind and other hazards now and in future decades, Bloomberg reported. The scores appear on or link from major real estate portals. MSCI completed its purchase of First Street on August 3, 2026.

Did Zillow remove climate risk scores?

Yes. Zillow removed the scores from more than 1 million listings in late 2025 after objections from the California Regional Multiple Listing Service, TechCrunch reported. Its listings still link to First Street's data, according to HousingWire.

Is there a First Street lawsuit update?

Florida filed suit on October 23, 2026, and Nebraska filed on August 27, 2026, according to HousingWire and 10/11 NOW. As of October 26, 2026, First Street had not filed a formal response in Florida, Tampa Free Press reported.

Key Takeaways

  • Florida's October 23, 2026, suit alleges First Street's climate risk scores lack adequate disclosure and seeks $10,000 per violation.
  • Nebraska filed a similar suit on August 27, 2026, and First Street and MSCI did not respond to requests for comment on Florida's case.
  • High flood risk homes sold at a rate about 27% lower in the Zillow figures the complaint cites, a Morabito Investment Group analysis found.

Bottom Line

Two states now allege in court that First Street's climate risk scores mislead buyers. The company has said its property-level models add factors federal maps leave out, such as heavy rainfall. Until the courts rule, investors may weigh these scores as one input among FEMA maps, insurer quotes and other models.

Image credit: Photo by Matt Paul on Unsplash.

Sources

Disclaimer: This article is for general information and education only. It is not investment, financial, legal, tax or accounting advice, and it is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or property. Morabito Investment Group does not guarantee that the information is complete, accurate or current. Figures, forecasts and opinions from third parties belong to their sources. All investments carry risk, including loss of principal, and past results do not guarantee future results. Do your own research and consult a licensed professional before making any investment, financing or other decision. You use this information at your own risk.

Read more articles